Skip to main content

Table 1 Literature review of case report with BCOR variant

From: Oculo-facio-cardio-dental (OFCD) syndrome: a case report

 

Current study

Ragge/2018/USA [9]

Kato/2018/Japan [17]

Morgan/2019/USA [18]

Zhang/2019/China [19]

Song/ 2019/Korea [20]

Tsuwaki/2005/Japan [13]

Di-Stefano/2015/Italy [14]

General information

Current case

Case 1

Case 2

Case 3

Case 4

Case 5

Case 6

Case 7

Case 8

Case 9

Age (year)

19

13

21

3

10

10

4

31

16

2

Gender

Female

Female

Male

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

BCOR variant

IVS11-2delA (c.4596-2delA)

c.2428C > T p.(Arg810*)

c.254C > T p.(Pro85Leu)

c.1209_1210delCC p.(Gln404Alafs*35)

Exon 4 c.265G > A

c.2514del(G)

c.1296delT

n/a

n/a

a de novo heterozygous del Xp11.4

Inheritance

De novo

De novo

Maternal

De novo

Denovo

 

De novo

De novo

  

Ocular

          

Microphthalmia

Left side

Bilateral

Bilateral (severe)

Bilateral

 

Left eye microphthalmia

  

Bilateral

Right eye

Anophthalmia

No

         

Congenital cataract

Bilateral

Bilateral

 

Bilateral

Bilateral

 + 

 + 

 + 

Bilateral

 

Glaucoma

n/a

Unilateral

   

In the right eye

  

 + 

 

Strabismus

 + 

        

 + 

Posterior embryotoxon

n/a

         

Other

Strabismus, left side

   

Artificial eye on the left side

Hemangioma near her right eyebrow

Bilateral ptosis, eyebrows curvature; mixed nystagmus; right eye

exohypertropia in primary position

  

Secondary cataract

Craniofacial

Long, broad face, concave facial profile in a lateral view, broad and protrusive mandible, prominent chin

    

no

    

Midface hypoplasia

 + 

 

 + 

       

Nasal anomalies

Broad nasal tip with separation of anterior nasal cartilage, bifid nasal tip

 

 + 

 

Broadening of the nasal tip

 

Broad nasal tip

Nasal tip was prominent and bulbous

Broad nasal tip separated nasal cartilage

Broad nasal tip, depressed nasal bridge

Ear anomalies

n/a

 

 + 

 + 

Preauricular tag

 

Protruding ears

No

Hearing on the right side is impaired slightly

Depressed nasal bridge

Cleft palate

Bifid uvula

   

–

 

 + 

no

no

 

High arched palate

 + 

  

 + 

  

 + 

   

Other

Thick eyebrows, narrow palate, and mandible, small mouth

 

Downslanting palpebral fissures, long face, tall forehead, thick eyebrows, Long Philtrum

 

Elongated, biprotrusive, with a thick lower lip

 

Flat and slightly long, dovetail-shaped uvula

  

Broad forehead, bifid uvula

Cardiac

          

ASD

Ostium secundum atrial septal defect

    

 + 

no

 + 

 

 + 

VSD

n/a

     

no

  

 + 

Other

Pulmonary artery hypertension, 4/4 leaky tricuspid valves

 

Triple heart sounds

      

Patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), persistent left superior vena cava

Dental

          

Late eruption of first teeth

n/a

 + 

 

 + 

n/a

     

Impacted teeth

Tooth 24

   

Tooth 23 was retracted and extruded

     

Delayed loss of primary dentition

n/a

 + 

      

 + 

 

Radiculomegaly

Canines, premolars, and lower anterior teeth

         

Tautodontism

Tooth 37

      

Teeth 13, 22, 23, 33, 34, 43, 44

  

Fused incisors

No

         

XQ

          

Other

Crowding with malposition of teeth 34,44, many dental caries (11,12,16,21,26,32,33,36,43,46,47) and periapical infection of tooth 33 with skin leaking

Double row of teeth

Recurrent dental infections

Abnormal crown canines + incisors

Malocclusion, anterior dental crowding, canines, central incisors, and

first premolars had Open apex

Long roots of her teeth with one missing tooth and first primary tooth loss at 6–7 years of age

Crossbite

Enamel hypoplasia, crown malformation

Lateral crossbite, Oligodontia, enamel hypoplasia,

 
 

Glossitis, stomatitis, heavy dental plaque, and calculus

         

Skeletal

          

Hands

Long and slender finder

Long Finger

5th Finger clinodactyly, long Finger

Long Finger

 

n/a

Short

No

 

Clinodactyly of

the fifth finger

Feet

IV-toes camptodactyly, I-hammer toes, long toes

Long toes

  

II-hammer toes

n/a

Hammer-type big toes; flexion deformity (2–4 toes of right foot and 2–3 toes of left foot)

No

I-long and wide toe, hammer-type flexion

of toes 2 through 4

Syndactyly 2–3, hammer toe of the second

Other

n/a

 

Scoliosis

   

Asymmetry of hand size

 

Forearm on the right side was slightly shorter

 

Developmental

          

ID

No intellect defect

    

n/a

    

Motor delay

Mental retardation

 

 + 

 

n/a

n/a

No

  

No

Speech delay

n/a

 

 + 

 

n/a

n/a

   

No

MRI findings

n/a

   

n/a

n/a

n/a

  

No

Lipomatous lesion

n/a

 

N

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

   

Other

   

Moderate BA, broad lateral ventricles

      

Other findings

          

GU anomalies

n/a

Urethral hypoplasia, renal dysplasia, renal, failure, VUR

Cryptorchidism, vesicoureteric reflux, primary enuresis

 

n/a

n/a

   

n/a

Other

 

Hypotonia

Primary enuresis

Stage III T-cell lymphoma

  

Bilateral papilloma of choroid plexus (PCP), supratentorial hydrocephalus

   
 

Current study

Mc Govern/2006/Ireland [21]

Atiq/2012/USA [22]

Danda/2014/India [23]

Martinho/2019/Portugal [8]

TĂ¼rkkahraman/2006/Turkey [24]

Verm/2014/India [25]

Zhou/2018/USA [26]

Zhu/2015/China [27]

General information

Current case

Case 10

Case 11

Case 12

Case 13

Case 14

Case 15

Case 16

Case 17

Case 18

Age (year)

19

8 days

39

8

6

26

15

24

5 weeks

7 months

Gender

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Female

Male

BCOR variant

IVS11-2delA (c.4596-2delA)

n/a

 

c.3490C > T (p.R1164*

    

p.R1163X (c.3487 C[T)

p. R540Q

Inheritance

De novo

Maternal

 

Heterozygous

     

Missense mutation

Microphthalmia

Left side

 + 

     

 + 

 + 

 

Anophthalmia

No

         

Congenital cataract

Bilateral

 

 + 

 + 

 + 

 + 

 + 

 + 

  

Glaucoma

n/a

      

 + 

No

 + 

Strabismus

 + 

         

Posterior embryotoxon

n/a

         

Other

Strabismus, left side

Deep-set eyes, short palpebral fissures

        

Craniofacial

Long, broad face, concave facial profile in a lateral view, broad and protrusive mandible, prominent chin

         

Midface hypoplasia

 + 

      

 + 

  

Nasal anomalies

Broad nasal tip with separation of anterior nasal cartilage, bifid nasal tip

       

Broad nasal tip

flat nasal bridge

 

Ear anomalies

n/a

       

Left hearing impairment

slightly low-set ears

 

Cleft palate

Bifid uvula

       

 + 

 

High arched palate

 + 

  

 + 

 + 

     

Other

Thick eyebrows, narrow palate, and mandible, small mouth

 

Extended long canine teeth, and nasal changes

High forehead

High nasal bridge

Class II malocclusion on a Class III skeletal base with a prognathic mandible, increased facial proportions, and facial asymmetry

long, narrow face

Long and narrow face, high nasal bridge, broad nasal tip with separated cartilages, and a long philtrum

eyebrows were laterally curved and thick

Class II malocclusion with an extremely deep overbite

Deeply set eyes and a broad nasal tip

long and narrow face

Class III malocclusion with a negative overjet and deep overbite

  

Cardiac

          

ASD

Ostium secundum atrial septal defect

 + 

-

   

 + 

 

 + 

 

VSD

n/a

 + 

-

 + 

  

 + 

 + 

  

Other

Pulmonary artery hypertension, 4/4 leaky tricuspid valves

Pulmonary valve stenosis

Mitral valve prolapse

Double outlet right ventricle, pulmonary stenosis

Prolapsed mitral valve

  

Patent ductus arteriosus (PDA)

 

Dental

          

Late eruption of first teeth

n/a

  

 + 

 + 

 

 + 

 + 

  

Impacted teeth

Tooth 24

    

Gummy smile, and crowded teeth

Extremely long roots and open apices

   

Delayed loss of primary dentition

n/a

  

 + 

   

 + 

  

Radiculomegaly

Canines, premolars, and lower anterior teeth

    

 + 

    

Tautodontism

Tooth 37

         

Fused incisors

No

         

XQ

   

Teethskeletal class I with severe vertical growth pattern, increased gonial angle, steep mandibular plane with retroclined incisors, and competent lips

   

Permanent teeth with extremely long roots and open apices. The roots of maxillary canines were in relation with the inferior border of the orbits and the lower canine roots almost reached the lower border of the mandible

The maxillary left central incisor had dilacerated root; all four third molars were congenitally missing

  

Other

Crowding with malposition of teeth 34,44, many dental caries (11,12,16,21,26,32,33,36,43,46,47) and periapical infection of tooth 33 with skin leaking

  

Bifid uvula

 

Numerous missing teeth

The first upper left molar, upper right canine, upper left lateral incisor, first upper left premolar, first upper right molar, first lower right molar, and first lower left molar are absent

    
 

Glossitis, stomatitis, heavy dental plaque, and calculus

         

Skeletal

          

Hands

Long and slender fingers

  

Camptodactyly of the 4th and 5th fingers (right > left), proximally placed thumbs, restricted supination, and pronation of the left forearm, camptodactyly and syndactyly of 2nd and 3rd toes, and sandal gap

Elbow radiographs at infancy showed left radioulnar synostosis

 

Misalignment

 

Fingers are normal

  

Feet

IV-toes camptodactyly, I-hammer toes, long toes

  

Sandal gaps, syndactyly and camptodactyly of toes

Sandal gap between the 1st and 2nd toes

Valgus foot

 

Syndactly of 2nd and 3rd toes

Right clubfoot, and bilateral 2–3 toe syndactyly

 

Other

n/a

Misalignment of right second toe

 

Short stature was observed (122 cm; < 3 SD)

Short stature (111 cm, < 3 SD)

     

Developmental

 

No

        

ID

No intellect defect

     

 + 

 

 + 

 

Motor delay

Mental retardation

       

 + 

 

Speech delay

n/a

       

 + 

 

MRI findings

n/a

         

Lipomatous lesion

n/a

         

Other

          

Other findings

          

GU anomalies

n/a

No

        

Other

 

Anterior positioning of the anus

Several episodes of hypoglycemia

several episodes of mental confusion associated with a blood glucose level of less

than 40 mg/dL

reactive lymph node

rare congenital disorder

   

Tall stature

Umbilical hernia at birth

 

CHD

structural brain anomalies

Axenfeld–Rieger syndrome, Lenz microphthalmia syndrome, and oculo-facio-cardio-dental (OFCD) syndrome

  1. BA brain atrophy, ASD atrial septal defect, VSD ventricular septal defect, ID Intellectual delay, Cm centimeter, SD standard deviation, MRI magnetic resonance imaging, VUR vesicoureteric reflux, CHD congenital heart defects, BCOR variant The BCOR gene is responsible for coding the BCL6 corepressor protein, N/a not applicable or not available, PDA patent ductus arteriosus, N normal